During the Closely Held Business Conference that was recently held by Ward and Smith, three attorneys from the firm shared useful guidance concerning strategies to distribute assets to mitigate estate and gift tax liability, utilize valuation discounts, coordinate estate planning documents with key business documents, and implement other techniques for business succession planning and estate planning.
The discussion featured insights from Phillip Cowan, a family law attorney, Lee Hodge, a business attorney, and Greg Peacock, a North Carolina State Bar Board Certified Specialist in estate planning, probate, and elder law.
Exercising a team approach is the key to minimizing tax liability when transitioning business assets to the next generation. “Bringing the financial advisor, CPA, and legal team into the planning sessions allows for a more coordinated, cohesive plan,” said Peacock.
Most successful closely held businesses are already structured within an LLC, S-Corp or C-Corp to ensure that personal assets are protected. “There may be multiple entities that own different classes of assets,” noted Hodge. “The choice of entity is significant and it affects how we work in a number of ways.”
There is no such thing as a one-size-fits-all approach when it comes to the transition of assets.
Harry and Wendy
Peacock shared the example of Harry and Wendy, a hypothetical 65-year-old couple, to illustrate the techniques that can be used in a succession plan. “Before we dive into this, it’s helpful to know that the current estate and gift tax exemption is $15 million,” commented Peacock. “It is indexed each year for inflation, and each spouse can utilize its $15 million exemption.”
Proper planning needs to occur to ensure that both spouses can use the exemption. The exemption can be used during lifetime, or it can be used at death, or it can be used partially during lifetime and partially at death.
“At death, if the assets exceed the remaining exemption, then the estate tax rate is 40 percent for every dollar over that exemption amount,” mentioned Peacock.
Harry and Wendy have two children, Adam and Bella, and five grandchildren. Their assets include a closely held farming operation worth $40 million, $10 million of marketable securities in a brokerage account, $2 million in a primary residence, and $5 million in investment real estate.
“Assuming that Harry and Wendy haven’t done any planning and only have wills, meaning that their assets will pass to the surviving spouse after the other’s death, the estate tax would be approximately $17 million after the use of that one exemption,” explained Peacock.
In this scenario, the couple has liquidity of $10 million. “After the date of death, there’s only nine months to come up with the additional $7 million, so this is obviously a liquidity issue that would be even worse if the numbers were bigger,” added Peacock.
Valuation Discounts
A valuation discount is an effective means of reducing tax liability. “As the name implies, this is a discount off of the valuation of the business or another type of asset that has been approved by the IRS,” said Hodge.
To estimate the value of the business, Hodge typically engages a business valuation expert. “This gives us an idea of the fair market value, as well as the size of the valuation discounts we can take off of that flatline valuation for estate and gift tax purposes, based on the underlying facts,” noted Hodge.
One of the two main valuation discounts is the discount for lack of marketability. “With a company that is publicly traded, you can sell stock if you need cash, but that is not possible with a closely held business,” Hodge commented. As such, you can reduce the value of an illiquid asset for estate and gift tax purposes since there is no liquid market for the asset. Liquidity is a significant factor in determining the size of the valuation discount for lack of marketability. Generally, assets with a smaller degree of liquidity, such as an equity interest in a closely held business or a piece of real estate, allow for a larger discount compared to assets with more liquidity, such as marketable securities.
The other main valuation discount is the discount for lack of control within a closely held business. The valuation discount for lack of control is available when you transfer a non-controlling interest in a closely held business. “We can transfer 99 percent of the economic rights to the children, or even move it down another generation, while still allowing Mom and Dad to retain full voting control over the business,” mentioned Hodge.
“With a privately held company valued at $100 million, for example, we could likely get a 40 percent discount, instantaneously significantly reducing the value of the company for estate and gift tax planning purposes. Now, we’re turning $1 of value into 60 cents of value from the perspective of the IRS,” explained Hodge.
Techniques for Succession Planning
There are three common techniques for succession planning. One is the gifting of Class B/non-voting interests into irrevocable trusts for children, grandchildren or other beneficiaries.
“The creation of the trust varies significantly from family to family,” added Peacock. “Some trusts are established to give the beneficiary the most control over the trust the IRS would allow. Others would require more control by a third party and more controls on the distributions.”
Wendy from the example above could potentially use her entire $15 million exemption by gifting a $15 million interest in the business into a trust for the two children.
“Without the discounting, Wendy could gift 37.5 percent of the business. Assuming a conservative 30 percent discount, she would be able to gift 53.5 percent. If the fair market value was $40 million, that would allow approximately $22 million of value to be transferred into the trust while only using $15 million of exemption,” said Peacock.
This type of transaction is also referred to as an estate freeze, because once the assets are gifted into the trust for the children, all of the post-gift appreciation remains in the trust and outside of the taxable estate of the parents. “Considering this could allow us to completely avoid the estate tax on the amount of appreciation, it could be more meaningful than any of the discounts we were discussing,” noted Peacock.
Are the Kids Actually Ready?
For those who are not sure if the children are ready to receive the assets of the business, a Spousal Lifetime Access Trust (SLAT) may be preferable. A SLAT allows spouses to transfer assets into a trust for the benefit of the other spouse.
Harry, for example, could use his $15 million exemption to transfer interest in the business into a SLAT for Wendy’s benefit. “The trust for Wendy can be structured in many different ways. Wendy could be the trustee, and so as long as Wendy and Harry remain married, they would both have access to the assets. Upon Wendy’s death, the assets would automatically pass to the children,” commented Peacock.
A SLAT allows the parents to retain access to the assets, while also utilizing the valuation discounts and the estate freeze planning techniques. “We’ve helped a number of clients where one spouse used the exemption to give and interest in the business to children, while the other spouse used the exemption to do a SLAT for the other one,” mentioned Peacock. “The point is we can mix and match any of these strategies to fit a client’s situation.”
Intentionally Defective Grantor Trusts
Many clients wonder why anyone would want to create something that is intentionally defective. The reason is that an installment sale of a business interest to an Intentionally Defective Grantor Trust (IDGT) can be an effective means of avoiding capital gains tax and leveraging discount valuation.
“This is what we typically go to after the exemption is utilized because it allows you to benefit from the discount valuation and the estate freeze strategies,” explained Peacock.
Each of the trusts can be created as generation-skipping trusts, making it possible to avoid estate tax for multiple generations. “These trusts can be established as dynasty trusts, meaning that the trustees could escape estate taxation for generations to come, even if the exemption has already been used,” added Peacock, “so it’s a very powerful technique.”
Generally, it is inadvisable to be too aggressive when dealing with the IRS, and this idea also applies to discount valuations. “Pigs get fat and hogs get slaughtered, so you definitely don’t want to ask for too much when it comes to a discount valuation, or you could get slaughtered by the IRS as part of an estate or gift tax audit,” said Hodge.
In some situations, one spouse may have a much larger balance sheet than the other spouse. “To gain access to the exemption, we may decide to transfer some assets to the spouse with the smaller balance sheet and then have the recipient spouse create a SLAT for the benefit of the spouse with the larger balance sheet,” noted Hodge. “Some may worry about what would happen to the assets in the event of a divorce; however, a SLAT can be structured such that the assets would pass to the children if the couple divorced.”
Using a certified professional who is experienced with business valuations is a best practice. “This is the person who will serve as the expert witness if the IRS audits your transaction, so you really want to be careful about who you choose to work with,” commented Hodge.
Buy-Sell Agreements
A buy-sell agreement can serve to protect the interests of the business from some of the interpersonal issues that arise from family dynamics. “There can be substantial numbers involved with these trusts and they can extend for multiple generations,” mentioned Hodge. “Because fractures within families are unfortunately not all that uncommon, it’s necessary to plan for these types of events. With a buy-sell agreement, we can deal with the most common issues.”
Using a buy-sell agreement can establish a set of ground rules, with the goal of removing friction points from the family relationship. “We want to create the highest probability that the family continues intact through the subsequent generations,” explained Hodge.
Buy-sell agreements usually include exempt transfer provisions to allow for estate planning within the family without consent of the other family members. “There’s no need for consent, provided that the business interests remain in the family,” added Hodge.
To protect the business from impulsive family members who want to transfer their business interests outside of the family, a buy-sell agreement normally would include a buy-out mechanism to purchase the equity interest of the family member that tried to transfer his/her ownership interest outside of the family. This would provide the other family members with a chance to buy out that person’s interest, typically at a 30 to 40 percent discount, and often with a 10 percent down payment, to prevent a liquidity issues for the company.
Similarly, buy-sell agreements can protect the family from divorce using the same discounts and small down payment requirements. This type of buy-out would apply if a non-family member spouse ended up with an ownership interest in the family business as part of the couple’s equitable distribution proceeding.
Another issue that can be addressed in a buy-sell agreement is the issue of siblings who are active in the family business versus siblings who are not active in the family business. However, this is an instance where a valuation discount typically does not apply if a sibling who is active in the family business has the right to buy out a passive family member. “Some people are just not interested in the business and as families grow over generations, the preferences of the individual family members become more disparate,” said Hodge.
Occasionally, passive siblings are provided with a right to put their interest in the business back to an active sibling. “Now, if we do that, we normally build in a 25 percent valuation discount, because the passive sibling is making the active sibling divert cash flow that otherwise would be used in the business,” noted Hodge.
Hodge commented that a buy-sell agreement also frequently will include a drag-along provision. As the name implies, a drag-along provision can force a family member to agree to a sale. “Sometimes, a significant purchase offer comes along, but one minority family member tries to block it,” commented Hodge. “A drag-along provision can force the dissenting minority family member to approve a sale if a simple majority or a super majority of the other shareholders wants to move forward with the sale transaction.”
Without a buy-sell agreement, a family member can sell to anyone, anytime. “Sometimes a disgruntled family member just wants to do anything they can to hurt the rest of the family, and so they’ll go sell their 10 percent ownership interest in the business to the main competitor,” mentioned Hodge. Having a properly structured buy-sell agreement in place can prevent this type of harmful action.
The ultimate goal with business succession planning is reducing potential friction points. “Another tool we use on the governance side is negative control rights,” explained Hodge. “This means we require a certain percentage of the family to approve major business decisions, such as selling the company, borrowing significant amounts of money, engaging in capex, or making large investments.” This is a mechanism to protect minority owners and passive family members from potential abusive actions by the active family members. Hodge advises against requiring a unanimous decision, as one family member who only owns a 5% interest in the business could block decisions that could be good for the business.
As with estate planning documents, there is no cookie-cutter buy-sell agreement that is the right answer for all closely held businesses. A properly structured buy-sell agreement will consider the various family dynamics, along with applicable business issues, and is a very valuable resource for a family-owned business.
Marital Property Rights
Marital rights impact how assets are divided in a separation or divorce, as well as inheritance rights and whether certain inheritance rights are waived, either completely or in a limited fashion. In North Carolina, marital property generally includes all, real and personal property acquired by either spouse during the marriage and before the date of separation, regardless of how title is held.
“An ownership interest in a business can be marital property if it is acquired during the marriage, even if only one spouse’s name is on the stock certificate or operating agreement,” noted Cowan.
Separate property generally includes assets acquired before the marriage, as well as property acquired during the marriage by gift or inheritance from a third party. “Things get confusing when you introduce the concept of mixed property, and this often applies to closely held businesses because any increase in the value of a separate business after the date of marriage that results from the efforts or contributions of either spouse, known as active appreciation, is typically treated as marital property,” added Cowan. “Passive appreciation, such as growth caused by market conditions or inflation, generally remains separate.”
If a business was valued at $500,000 on the date of marriage, for example, and $2 million on the date of separation, then some or all of the $1.5 million in appreciation could be a marital asset, depending on how much of that growth is attributable to the efforts of the spouses rather than to passive factors.
In a case where a married child owns a percent of a family business, part of that ownership interest may have a marital component. “In a divorce the other spouse can use discovery and subpoenas to obtain the business’s financial records, and in some cases the business itself may be joined as a party to the equitable distribution action,” mentioned Cowan.
Determining the value of the business on the date of marriage and on the date of separation, as well as how much of the appreciation was active versus passive, can become an expensive, time-consuming task that often requires competing expert valuations. A premarital agreement can specify which assets, including business interests and their future appreciation, will remain separate property, without a marital component.
“People have a misconception that premarital agreements are like a broad blanket statement, but we can tailor them very narrowly to the interests of the business and inheritance rights,” explained Cowan.
Doing so can make it easier to have a conversation about the agreement. “This is usually a difficult conversation, but having the agreement narrowly tailored softens the blow,” said Cowan. “Similarly, with a post-marital agreement, having it specifically address the definition of separate property in the event of divorce makes it easier to understand and talk about.”
Hodge added that: “We built a cure right into a buy-sell agreement for a family we recently worked with, stating that if a child or grandchild gets married without a premarital agreement, we can obtain a post-marital agreement. If they don’t, then the family will have the right to buy out that child’s interest in the family entities at a huge discount. This really helps to smooth the conversation with the future in-laws.”
Elective Share
Another spousal right that can be waived through a pre-marital or post-marital agreement is the elective share. The elective share refers to the right a surviving spouse may have to the estate of a deceased spouse.
In the absence of an agreement, regardless of a Last Will and Testament, a surviving spouse will have a right to a percentage of the estate based on the number of years of the marriage:
- 50 percent if married 15 years or more
- 33 percent if married between 10 and 15 years
- 25 percent if married between 5 and 10 years
- 15 percent if married less than 5 years
“Significantly, there is no distinction between separate and marital property, as there would be in a divorce,” mentioned Cowan. “That can be a real problem for business owners who expect their children who work in the business to inherit it, because a surviving spouse may be able to override the estate plan if the elective share has not been addressed.”
Premarital and post-marital agreements can also address portability. Portability allows a surviving spouse to use any federal estate tax exemption left unused by the first spouse to die, which in 2026 can be as much as $15 million. “In a case where one spouse has significantly more assets than the other, the less wealthy spouse can contractually require the executor of the deceased spouse’s estate to file an estate tax return electing portability, so the unused exemption passes to the survivor, and that can be huge,” added Cowan.
“I was involved in a situation where a post-marital agreement required the filing of a portability return. The first spouse died, and we were not involved in the will or in the administration of that spouse’s estate. A couple of years later, we learned that the portability return had not been filed, but because the requirement was in the post-marital agreement, we were able to have the estate reopened and the portability return filed,” concluded Cowan.
An audience member commented: “We just went through this process with our family with Ward and Smith. Don’t wait, because there are a lot of variables to consider during the planning process, but it is definitely worth the time and effort.”